Class #15 Mencius on Human Nature (I) Readings: Mencius, Readings 2 The readings for today and Monday are
somewhat shorter than the other selections. This is because they focus on
passages key to Mencius's most distinctive and influential doctrine: the
goodness of human nature. Last week, we saw that Mencius pictured actual
human beings in terms of the potential for moral excellence within them - trying
to illustrate to woefully amoral warlords that their ethical instincts were
actually alive, and pointing them towards the type of good conduct that
Confucians sought in the True King. The doctrine of the goodness of human
nature articulates that view theoretically. On Friday, we'll begin by considering passage 2A.2, which
is the Mencius's most detailed look at the experience of sagely
certainty - something Mencius is pictured as having achieved. In this
passage we will encounter a "psychology": an analysis of the structure of
the morally responsive mind and its development. The stress lies on the
way that the mind gains full leadership over the embodied person. There is
no view of a "mind/body" split (very common in the West), rather, the issue is
how we can mobilize ourselves to turn our entire persons into an agent for our
morally responsive consciousness - so that when we act, we act out the perfect
and powerful instincts that our feelings spontaneously give to us. The
issue is primarily cast in terms of gaining control over a bodily
force/substance that was called qi. So
critical is passage 2A.2 to our understanding of Mencius that it will occupy us
for most of today's class and form the foundation of our more direct
consideration on Monday of passages directly expounding the doctrine of the
goodness of human nature.